What are your top 5 songs on Smashing Pumpkins Mellon Collie And The Infinite Sadness?
Here's mine in no particular order
>Galapagos
>Tales Of A Scorched Earth
>To Forgive
>Jellybelly
>Zero
What are your top 5 songs on Smashing Pumpkins Mellon Collie And The Infinite Sadness?
Here's mine in no particular order
>Galapagos
>Tales Of A Scorched Earth
>To Forgive
>Jellybelly
>Zero
Other urls found in this thread:
mega.nz
twitter.com
cupid de locke
here is no why
thirty-three
1979
tonight tonight
1979
Tonight, Tonight
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
Jellybelly
Muzzle
Here Is No Why and Tales Of a Scorched Earth are up there too
Thru The Eyes Of Ruby is up there for me aswell
1979
Tonight, Tonight
Zero
Cupid de Locke
Where Boys Fear to Tread
Mellon Collie
Galapogos
Porcelina Of the Vast Oceans
In the Arms of Sleep (underrated)
1979
Honorable mention: We Only Come Out at Night because everyone rips on it and I like it.
Why does everyone rip on it?
i don't know why, i think it's pretty good too
To Forgive
Muzzle
Porcelina
Thirty-three
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
bless this thread
Used to listen to this beginning to end on a weekly basis back in my freshman year of high school. Makes this a bit tough, but here goes!
Cupid de Locke
Bodies
1979
Where Boys Fear to Tread
Stumbleine (I guess)
'We Only' is a dope track.
tonight tonight
to forgive
xyu
love
an ode to no one
props to having the best thread currently on Sup Forums op
i only listen for the singles :?)
oh god you're missing out
Tonight Tonight
Bullet With Butterfly Wings
Zero
1979
Thirty Three
some of the singles from this album are among my least favourite from it
it's definitely worth giving the whole thing a listen
Thats cool man whatever floats your boat
1979
Tonight Tonight
Here Is No Why
Jellybelly
Muzzle
>1979
>Thru The Eyes of Ruby
>Zero
>(Fuck You) An Ode To No One
>Porcelina
Looks like 1979 is on pretty much everyone's top 5
when everyones list has 1979
I WONT DENY THE PAIN, I WONT DENNNNNY THE CHANGE
It's one of the greatest songs of all time. Regardless of what Billy thinks.
Does everyone listen to this album with the tracks in order of the vinyl release?
I hope so. If not, youre missing out.
oh shit this has been one of my favorites since high school I don't think I do this
Oh shit man, I gotta do this now i wasn't even aware the vinyl release had a different track listing
this
what is the last track (infinite sadness)?
cheers, assumed that it was probably an extended version of that
just deleted that cause not actually sure now
No. The bonus tracks are straight up garbage and the track order is retarded
1979
Bodies
Tonight, Tonight
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
Zero
It's the song "Infinite Sadness". it's a boring melotron-driven instrumental that was a crappy Siamese Dream outtake.
beautiful
cupid de locke
thirty three
here is no why
take me down or we only come out at night
Tonight, Tonight
Bodies
X.Y.U
Stumbleine
Farewell and Goodnight
My alternate pick is Bullet with Butterfly Wings.
Where Boys Fear to Tread
XYU
Galapagos
Jellybelly
To Forgive
Not in any specific order:
Tonight, Tonight
Here Is No Why
To Forgive
Love
1979
The track order makes the album consistent and have a great flow.
I have no idea what bonus tracks you are talking about.
Are you talking about the vinyl tracklist?
Yeah
You didn't notice theres two extra tracks?
No
Jellybelly
Ruby
xyu
farewell and goodnight
stumbleine
>Used to listen to this beginning to end
me too. every time before sleeping
>The track order makes the album consistent and have a great flow.
>extra tracks? what?
Embarrassing
Porcelina
1979
Zero
By Starlight
Jellybelly
mellon collie and the infinite sadness
1979
take me down
cupid de locke
to forgive maybe or jellybelly
if I'm in a shitty mood i prefer the metal songs lol
also i think the title track is underrated
and the entire album kinda falls apart on disc 2
porcelina
beautiful
1979
jellybelly
zero
>Here is No Why
>To Forgive
>Take Me Down
>Thirty Three
>By Starlight
Honorable mentions:
>Galapagos
>Cupid De Locke
>We Only Come Out at Night
Thirty-Three
Here Is No Why
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
Take Me Down
8/10 good taste
5/10
6/10
6/10
6/10
7/10
4/10 grow up
5/10
7/10
6/10
6/10
5/10
4/10
1/10 kill yourself
4/10 there's a second disc you know
7/10
5/10
3/10 try-hard
4/10
5/10
5/10
0/10 autist who quotes every post ITT
You don't seem to understand.
I take the CD version and reorder the tracks so they are the same as the vinyl version.
The extra tracks on the vinyl version do not matter because they are nonexistent on the CD version. There are no extra tracks on the CD version.
>0/10
Not possible
Then that's not the vinyl version is it?
You are beyond retarded
Can you imagine putting songs in an order that resembles the vinyl version? That's what I do.
I don't know how to explain it any better. I'm sorry.
So you misspoke
Yes I did
1. Here Is No Why
2. Zero
3. 1979
4. We Only Come out at Night
5. Farewell and Goodnight
Go fuck yourself faggot
;-; im sorry i just really like the first half
Here Is No Why
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
By Starlight
Jellybelly
Why is the vinyl for this so fucking expensive? Fuck, why are all Smashing Pumpkin vinyls so fucking expensive?
And I just looked it up, it's not even the original vinyl track listing. WTF?
hey I actually have this album rated song by song and have listened to it 40+ times all the way through so heres a list from an "expert"
>1979
>Muzzle
>Beautiful
>By Starlight
>We Only Come Out at Night
Here's the album with the vinyl tracklist and bonus tracks.
mega.nz
You didn't man, the guy responding is beyond retarded as anyone could have assumed you reordered the tracks as the same as the vinyl listing, i did anyway
You literally said in your original post you put them in order of the track listing, So you didn't misspeak.
This particular manner of being retarded is called being "intellectually dishonest."
i'm not really a big SP fan at all desu, but cupid de locke is one of my favorite songs ever
In order
>Porcelina Vast Oceans
>Tonight Tonight
>Thirty Three
>Cupid De Locke
>Farewell and Goodnight
Fuck 1979, honestly one of the worst songs in the album in comparison to everything else
1-5: bullet with butterfly wings
cherub rock
tristessa
suffer
space boy
daydream
bullet
the only choice really
1. 1979
2. Galapogos
3. Bullet With Butterfly Wings
4. Thirty Three
5. Thru The Eyes Of Ruby
2/10
here is no why
to forgive
galapogos
1979 (fuck you)
stumbleine
everyone else should be executed for not including Ruby
fuck
In no order
Here is no why
Zero
Jelly Belly
An Ode to no one
Tonight Tonight
There are too many to pick only five songs
Bodies = #1 breakup song hands down.
Only five? You're killing me OP!
Here goes:
-Jellybelly
-Muzzle
-Bodies
-1979
-Thru the yes of ruby
Honorable mentions :
-Porcelina
-In the arms of sleep
here is no why
cupid de locke
thru the eyes of ruby
33
jellybelly
honorable mentions:
tonight tonight
to forgive
love
galapogos
muzzle
porcelina
take me down
where boys fear to tread
bodies
1979
tales of a scorched earth
stumbeleine
xyu
we only come out at night
beautiful
lily
by starlight
farewell and goodnight
Which isn't the vinyl tracklisting because it's missing songs
He didn't. Learn to read
Bodies
Here is no why
To Forgive
Thirty-Three
1979
By Starlight
I love the guitar ending
this fucking hurts to do, this was my favorite album when i was a depressed addict in my early 20s. also jimmy chamberlain is a god.
Galapogos - just a god tier song when you'e done spiraling and settling deeply into depression.
>and rescue me from me, and all that i believe
Tonight Tonight - great for when you get that fleeting feeling of hope
>believe in me like i believe in you
Zero - the numbness of life. when i was addicted to spice this was my zombied-out song
>im in love with my sadness
Cupid de Locke - this song is just endlessly endearing to me, i love the music, it feels like im in a medieval ballroom watching minstrels dance and shit. it's almost like the place i wanted drugs to take me to.
>we seek the unseekable and speak the unspeakable
Thru the Eyes of Ruby - this song is perfect. i dont really know what else to say about it
>to appear to disappear beneath your darkest fears
8/10 great taste
7/10
5/10
1/10 give up on music
2/10 you are as funny as James Iha
5/10
5/10
6/10
6/10
5/10 no one asked for honorable mentions
5/10
5/10 this isn't your personal blog
this isnt ur personal pitchfork either
In order of appearance:
Zero
Muzzle
Where Boys Fear to Tread
XYU
We Only Come Out At Night