this, it's great. The others in the sort-of trilogy aren't bad either
Luis Brooks
Just listing a bunch of historical movies I've seen. Quality varies and most of them are probably hard to find now. There might be some movies in between without battles.
Sokolovo Alexander Nevsky Andrey Rublyov Ivan Grozny Osvobozeni Admiral Nachimov Admiral Usakov Bezhlavy Jezdec Bojovali za vlast Leningradske nebe Pribeh opravdoveho cloveka udalost ve ctverci 36-80 War and peace Zpivajici eskadra Atentat Dny Zrady Jan Hus Jan Zizka Proti Vsem Udoli vcel Marketa lazarova Nebesti Jezdci Dark blue world Dobry vojak svejk Jan Rohac z Dube Janosik Zborov Zikmund receny Selma rysava With fire and sword Potop Pan Wolodyjowski Fate of a man Strafbat Koraby utoci Normandie Niemen Zena zenecka a katusa
Aiden Morgan
Awesome, thanks.
Robert James
Skanderbeg (1954)
Jonathan Cook
Remembered a couple more
Sarajvesky atentat Přivoláme na sebe palbu Opus pro smrtihlava Nebesky louda kozi roh Brána k Domovu Seventeen Moments of Spring dacii black cross
Fucking hell, why don't they make shit like this anymore? Every battle in movies is some fantasy CGI shitfest. I can't even remember the last good battle scene. Probably Kingdom of Heaven.
Jose Scott
Because they are lazy fucks that prefer paying one person to CGI all the shit up instead of working with actual people. I bet that there would be extras willing to do it even for free, i know i would.
Jaxson White
Pretty interesting thread guys.
Landon Stewart
sup jani
Logan Torres
I was actually an extra in World War Z. For free, except for the food we got on set. We had to form phalanxes and fight zombies with spears and riot police gear and shit. The zombies were not there cause they were supposed to be CGI, and it was super fucking awkward. It was supposed to be a huge battle scene, but it was eventually cut in favor of Brad Pitt playing hide and seek with zombies in a Pepsi commercial.
Evan Thomas
Not necessarily a conventional battle but the Battle of Algiers protest and riot sequences look incredible due to the number of extras on screen.
Nicholas Nelson
>Old Eastern European historical movies apparently had a shitton of great battle scenes, as they had like a million extras on set. not that hard to do when you can get the national conscripted army to play in them since they lived on water and bread and were already used to being commanded around. its much harder to do with real actors. war and peace for example where more than 20k military personnel took part in filming but also in the eclipse of the crescent moon with around 5k soldiers
Blake Johnson
So just shoot in a country that still has a lot of free manpower for this shit. It worked with Waterloo.
Benjamin Thompson
>implying people today wouldn't be an extra in a big movie for free
The reason you don't see many extras anymore is unions.
Eli Gomez
There was a series about some Russian dude that becomes Sultan of some Sandnigger country I think it came out in the 80's. Starts out with Russians getting wrecked by Mongols and he gets sold into slavery as a child and ends up in some desert kingdom.
Forgot what it was called but really wanted to watch it.
Grayson Roberts
my point was specifically about using the conscripted army. it makes everything cheaper and easier to organise. and also a push from the Communist party. that also helps
Samuel Phillips
>I can't even remember the last good battle scene.
Scenes (with terrible added music) from Der große König, Germany 1942. According to wikipedia, actual soldiers were made available. Also, whereas in previos historic monumental battle scenes, the armies could often not be told apart, Harlan had the Prussians always attack from the left, Austrians from the right and gave each army their own music.
James Morales
This is so infuriating. If that scene was completed and left in the movie as intended, it would have been at least okay. If they had spent the money on makeup and extras and gotten real people to be the zombies, it would have been awesome. Basically anything else would have been better than what we got.