What was your first 5 star album?

What was your first 5 star album?

my black metal demo I made when I was 13

The Downward Spiral

In Rainbows

Dots and Loops

In the Court of the Crimson King

Dude I came to this post

I mean fuck, I came to post this

Spiderland

I always used to regard OK Computer as their magnum opus, but for the last couple years, I've come to realize that In Rainbows very well might be one of the best albums of the last decade. It just gets better with age and the replay value has somehow increased

No album gets 5 stars from me, at least not on RYM. I'm mostly a singles guy there, anyway.