Why didn't you like this movie? I thought it was miles better than Force Awakens

Why didn't you like this movie? I thought it was miles better than Force Awakens.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=Jm5czvOeeig
youtube.com/watch?v=GWqTj-LuXCs
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

anything is better than fa

Anyone who says they liked TFA more than RO is either a RLM fanboy or someone fishing for (You)s

>>he paid to see mouse shit

KUK

I loved it. I loved TFA as well. I love all of Star Wars.

I do like it. I can get past the politically correct overtones easily. I liked it.

FA a shit

this

>boring plot
>makes a big deal of killing of characters that had no real development before hand
>CGI Moff-kun
>another scene where a quirky gurl gives a motivational speech in front of a bunch of representatives around a large round table
>lol remember a new hope

it was, but that still didn't make it good

the finale was pretty cool though

what PC overtones?

>lol remember a new hope

I thought you were making fun of RO not TFA

>hey, look! It's R2D2 and C3PO! remember them! Aren't they so cool, despite the fact that it literally doesn't make any sense for them to be in that spot?

I'll bite, why doesn't it make sense? They were on a Rebel ship in ANH, why would they not be at a Rebel base?

It was literally fanfiction

I love all of Star Wars EXCEPT The Force Awakens. It was such a blatant remake that so thoroughly invalidated the previous 6 movies while being so cunningly designed to appeal to everything cancerous about the Star Wars fandom with absolutely none of the charm or world building of ANY of the others that I just felt empty and vaguely disgusted after seeing it.

I liked Rogue One though.

Because they're on the ship with Leia, and Leia wasn't at the council meeting, meaning that she was already on the ship by the time that Rogue One took off.

it was too boring in the middle

and no reason why robo-black died

The hype from seeing the fleet warp in over Scarif is the reason I watch Star Wars at all.

Why did we never see these big imperial security droids in any of the subsequent movies?

The first two-thirds were shit. Final third had some decent action. The characters were better in death than they were in life.

I agree with this. It was excruciatingly boring.

-The fight scenes had neither tension or fun to them, but more of a "let's hurry this up so we can get to the next scene".
-No character development, which would have been useful even if we knew before hand they were doomed. I simply didn't care about any of the characters and they were all highly forgettable.
-Pointless Kung fu guy to appeal to the Chinese. I didn't even know what his or his even more useless sidekicks names were.
-Unbelievably stupid macguffin driving the plot. In an age of lightspeed engines, people still rely on physical media to hold data?
-The main female made to be a bad ass fighter with no explanation or need or reason other than pandering to feminist. I love bad ass ladies, as long as there is a logical reason for it.
-"A 13 year old girl was my best mercenary!" managed to be a more cringey moment than hating sand, neat tricks, choking on aspirations, high ground and Ewoks combined.
-For what purpose was Princess Leia with the main attack fleet?
-Literally the only interesting part was Darth Vader whooping ass... all 2 minutes of it. They could have just put this in as an extra features on a New Hope re-release and skipped the rest of this pointless movie.

>first two-thirds were shit
are you serious? The last third had the least action. the days leading up to the shutdown were dead as fuck

I think you need to watch the movie again or perhaps reassess your perception of time.

This what a waste not to have the rebel base be on Dantooine which we know from IV was there base for a time

The base on dantooine was already abandoned by the time of rogue one

it was?

but I did

Haven't seen it yet, I am still waiting for the blueray

TFA was better because it had a fucking script.

this

The problem with the characters wasn't that they didn't have any development, it's that there weren't any characters at all.

Eh the first order was really cool (albeit completely out of fucking nowhere). It's still maybe the most memorable thing about the movie.

Poe pretty coo.

I hated it. The only part I was invested in was the poorly edited and written first act.

Aside from how I felt, it was useless and boring. I was sitting next to one of the only children in the theater and the eight year old chink was bored to tears, he only perked up when he saw things he recognized.
It's a movie made for millennials who consider themselves star wars fans yet hate the prequels.

Because it was overall pretty dull, tried to compensate for weak characters by having action sequences that to on for too long, and was, if anything, considerably worse than Force Awakens.

They were both stupid but TFA's stupidity was at least fun. There wasn't any stormtrooper busting out his space club in this movie, just dumb shit like vader not bothering to use the force to grab the plans as he was slowly walking towards the guy trying to pass them off. Or magic chinese man somehow using the force to not get shot by slowly inching forwards.

...

>miles better than Force Awakens.
That is placing the bar underground.

The foreign accents were off-putting to be honest.

I literally forgot this movie existed

The Force Awakens and Rogue One have different faults.

youtube.com/watch?v=Jm5czvOeeig

youtube.com/watch?v=GWqTj-LuXCs

After analysing over the movies and watching them again, RO is definitely up there. The cast and characters are well done, enough to convey their motives and characteristics. TFA and even the older movies had much flatter characters.
They also develop the characters just enough before they were all killed off, which might be why some people think that they were boring or underdeveloped. The lead up to the scene of the first movie was spectacular. A real good finish to what the movie was. It wasn't trying to be the best out of the series, it just tells its part of the story and tells it well. There's something comforting about that.
I'll miss those characters though.

>I love all of Star Wars EXCEPT The Force Awakens.
Nice meme. We get it youre an edgy teenager.

Not original in even the slightest. If anything it's even more derivative of the source material than TFA.

Also the characters are all copied from other instances of the franchise.

>Rogue One before the Vader scene
>6.5/10 movie
>Rogue One afte the Vader scene
>9/10 film

>Good guys look like Jihadists

What did they mean by this?

maybe they didnt mean anything by this and you're only seeing things because you look at everything through the lense of youe own underlying agenda

>Hehehe good goy, nothing ever has meaning, it's just coincidece... good goy eheheheheheheheheh

The Darth Vader scene was nice but everything else sucked, felt like a fan-film sometimes.

>yesss good goy, remember that jews are behind everything and be vocal about it! keep fueling that anti-semitism machine!

I dontknow i loved it, specially if compared to TFA.

Chi Taking wasnt the best, but it was good enough for me and defintivly better than Harrison Ford pretending to give a fuck about han solo in TFA.

The characters were awesome the rebellion and the empire were fleshed out like never before (what? You thought this movie was about the human characters? Lol. Thats like saying that jurassic world was about chris prat and not the dinosaurs). The characters on TFA were a Mary Sue and a storm trooper that went from hating violence and wanted to run away from it to murdering all of his childhood friends just because a vagina was in danger.

The bad guy was also great, loved the lead villian in R1, on the other hand i dont even want to talk about kylo Ren...

*cgi tarkin, dont know why it was autocorrected to chi talking

The only surprise was seeing clone troopers piloting the hover tank on desert planet, surprised Disney allowed that.

>TFA had a script