FRA: Parlez-vous votre langue régionale? Quelle est-elle? Parlez-vous souvent votre langue? Combien de gents conaissez-vous qui parlent votre langue?
ITA: Parlate la vostra lingua regionale? Qual'è? La parlate spesso? Quanta gente conoscete che parla la vostra lingua?
ESP: ¿Habléis vuestra lengua regional? ¿Cual es ella? ¿Habléis vuestra lengua con freuencia? ¿Cuantas personas conocéis que hablan vuestra lengua?
POR: Falais vosso idioma regional? Qual é? Falais vosso idioma com freqüência? Quantas pessoas conheceis quem falan vosso idioma?
ENG: Do you speak your regional language? Which one is it? Do you speak your language frequently? How many people do you know who can speak your language?
N'utilisez pas google translator svp. Les phrases espagnoles sont incorrectes. Mais bon fil
Gavin Watson
Everyone in Portugal speaks portuguese except like 15,000 who speak Mirandese
Levi King
Yes, galician. Well, with some friends I speak it, I always speak galician with my parents and other relatives. Everybody I know can speak it except immigrants obviously,
Anthony Taylor
I'm amused by you two, Recently I listened a podcast about Vlad III.
Josiah Richardson
>Parlez-vous votre langue régionale? That would be Tourangeau...literally just French as it's spoken in Paris with some differences. >Parlez-vous souvent votre langue? No. >Combien de gents conaissez-vous qui parlent votre langue? None.
Jordan Morgan
Le lingue regionali d'Italia possono essere etichettate come gruppo di dialetti della stessa tipologia, o come lingua letteraia sviluppatasi da uno specifico dialetto della sua sprachbund
i.e. con piemontese si può indentificare o l'insieme di dialetti di tipo piemontese o il torinese letterario in cui sono scritte le maggiori opere della lingua piemontese.
Pas vraiment, ou au moin pas ici en Italie: je suis de la Val Cluson ( qu'elle est une vallée occitanophone piemontaise ), et même si avec l'influence italienne les dialect provençals soyent moins parlés aujourd'hui, l'identité occitane, avec sa langue, est bien mieux conservée ici qu'en France
Pido perdón, intentaré de hacer menos errores
Connor Miller
Romanian doesn't have different dialects, only slight accents between different regions. That map is shit!
Jack Watson
are those dialects at the austrian and french borders so weird that this map doesn't clasify them as italian?
Nicholas Ortiz
Why is there so much hate between Romanians?? YOU SCUM FUCKS!
Jaxson Gomez
fuck you too, bozgorshit
Wyatt Reyes
>I shit my pants mommy, bozgor did it
Wyatt James
Unluckily My region is spanish speaking because the eternal c*stillian destroyed the local language.
BASED Andalú compatriota. The eternal c*astillian fucked our nation.
Colton Ramirez
Why is France such a culture-killing blob?
Jayden Walker
because people should speak normally and stop having those retarded accents
Jason James
What a shitty portuguese you got there:
''Falam o vosso idioma regional?Qual é?Falam com frequência?Quantas pessoas vocês conhecem que falam o vosso idioma?''
Robert Collins
>implying bozgors aren't to blame for you shitting your pants
Levi Johnson
fair, although I didn't really want to write it using the formal vocês
I know my Portuguese is not quite as good as it should be, but I still try to give it a shot each time I can
James Wood
THERE YOU GO, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN! Need I say more?!
Isaac Scott
Yes, Catalan, yes, almost everybody but most sons of immigrants from other parts of Spain speak it poorly and mixing languages and even locals speak it badly beacuse watching TV and movies in Spanish. Plus right now about more than 20% of the population isn't even from Spain and almost everybody everywhere use Spanish as first language so in a couple of generations it will disappear.
Eli Rivera
The sardinian variant of my village, pretty much every one I know can speak their local language, I use it everyday
Dylan Turner
No, they are French and German dialects
Brayden Martinez
>m-muh republic that's literally it bunch of self righteous faggots giving themselves an importance they don't have I hate france so fucking much, can't wait for the great kebabing
Isaiah Bailey
on the western border with France, there are a series of dialects of Occitan, on the border with France and Switzerland there's Arpitan, and dulcis in fundo on the Austrian border a dialect of Bavarian is spoken
Robert Sanchez
although nowadays in Sudtirol standard German is replacing the local language
David Sanders
t. BOZGOR
Christopher Cruz
Nice to know, so Occitan survived in Italy?
Ayden Hall
>Parlate la vostra lingua regionale? Eia(Si). >Qual'è? Gaddhuresu(Gallurese). >La parlate spesso? Ugna dì cu li mei a lu telefonu. Candu torru a lu me paesi quasi cun tutti, parenti e amichi.(Ogni giorno con i miei al telefono. Quando torno al mio paese quasi con tutti, parenti e amici). >Quanta gente conoscete che parla la vostra lingua? Praticamenti tutti li mè paesani faeddhani lu dialettu, ancora si decu dì chi li più cioani, come in ugna locu chisti di, faeddhani sempri più l'italianu.(Praticamente tutti i miei compaesani parlano il dialetto, anche se devo dire che i più giovani, come un pò dappertutto di questi giorni, parlano sempre di più l'Italiano).
Lucas Anderson
Is cheese the only thing that survived ultra centralization?
Nolan Johnson
every dialect survived in Italy
Xavier Peterson
unity and homogeneity is better in 99% of cases.
Jordan Anderson
What would the 56% seppo know about historical nations
Joseph Wood
Only for the dominant culture
David Kelly
>what would the person from the multicultural country know about the flaws of multiculturalism
Sure, but if everyone becomes part of the dominant culture that doesn't matter.
Mason Howard
...
Logan Williams
why does the dad have a faggot numale hairstyle?
Caleb Hill
He's most probably just balding in the wrong spots
Luke Martin
So much wrong with this post
Luke Green
please explain why. how does a country benefit from having dozens of cultures and languages as opposed to one?
Leo Thomas
That's not the point
1. You think USA is more multicultural than Italy or Spain and that's wrong 2. Why do you want to kill other cultures for the sake of the dominant one? Instead of having one centralized blob like France why not France + Occitania + Brittany etc each with their own culture? Cultural heterogeneity is the best thing about romance Europe, killing local languages like France did is a crime against humanity
Jack Bailey
Thank you for not including our language there, we also think that the other Latins are scumbags and don't want to have anything else to do with them than we already are
Lucas Cox
Did the Italians catch you stealing shit again or something, gypsy?
Wyatt Wright
>1. You think USA is more multicultural than Italy or Spain and that's wrong
at literally no point did I ever say that.
>2. Why do you want to kill other cultures for the sake of the dominant one?
countries with multiple linguistic groups are prone to breaking up and overall weaker. see the examples of Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, Soviet Union, and China. all of these socialist states divided except China, which is coincidentally the only one that was ethnically homogeneous. Once you wipe out the minority groups its a lot harder to bring them back, so you've effectively permanently expanded your country.
Dominic Thompson
Daca-ti place sa culegi capsuni n-am ce sa-ti fac
Easton Butler
>at literally no point did I ever say that.
>what would the person from the multicultural country know about the flaws of multiculturalism "the multicultural country". when you have only two languages and zero cultures. lol
>countries with multiple linguistic groups are prone to breaking up Yes, that's the point Small country that can preserve their own culture = good Big blob that kills everything not in line with the standard culture = bad
Slovenia, Croatia = good Yugoslavia = bad
Do you understand?
Ian Bell
also
>China >ethnically homogeneous my sides
Nathaniel Thompson
Yes, I understand your opinion that you prefer many tiny states as opposed to fewer homogeneous states. But you still haven't explained why. Why?
China is 91% Han Chinese.
Asher Jackson
I was born in the south, but my family is from the centre, so my accent has some characteristics from there. People always ask me if I'm a northerner, because it's kind of similar.
Carson Davis
Do I really have to explain why I want to preserve cultures? If you lived in a multicultural nation you wouldn't ask why I can travel for 100km and barely understand the language, taste foods I never tried before and observe traditions I had no idea even existed Cultural heterogeneity is a treasure of humankind, would you rather travel for 2000km and find the same shit everywhere? Same language, same mentality, same food, same people, nothing new to find. Is this the world you want?
I don't want the whole world to have the same culture. I'm just saying it's objectively the best course of action for any country to squash its minorities, even if it makes you feel sad.
Thomas Carter
And I'm saying it's the best course for minorities to squash the countries Fuck your artificial standardized blobs, the Europe of a hundred flags is the real Europe
Cameron Rivera
so you would be okay with Italy being divided into 12 or so new countries?
Cooper Kelly
Same thing here, all the difference between all these French ""dialects"" are just slight differences in intonations amd speech patterns.
Jayden Ward
Fuck yes I'm for a federalized Europe divided among actual ethnolinguistic borders, like Yann Fouere theorized, instead of the arbitrary artificial borders we have now
Luis Reyes
so what happens when the countries that don't balkanize invade and dominate all the Italian microstates?
Lincoln Mitchell
>province >""""culture""""
Fucking your sister isn’t a culture.
Ryder Cooper
Did you miss the part about 'federalized Europe'? In any case I'd laugh my ass off
Carter Gomez
ah okay so your perfect system only works in a hypothetical world. thanks for playing
Colton Peterson
>hurr why is your theory only a theory The European Union used to be only a hypothetical world aswell
Kayden Green
I'm from Friuli (north eastern Italy), and I speak the regional dialect. My grandparents on my mother side only speak Friulano and my mother and her relatives mostly use it to communicate. Most people of all ages still speak it, especially in little villages.
Jaxon Williams
>Most people of all ages still speak it, especially in little villages.
t. terrone del nord
Carter Turner
Kek. Non proprio, dai. Quasi tutti parlano italiano e lo parlano bene, non siamo veneti. Si parla tanto in dialetto, ma è quasi una seconda lingua.
