Battle of geonosis

>battle of geonosis
>clones save the surviving jedi, since the dumbfucks thought fighting completely outnumbered in the middle of an arena built on top of a battle Droid factory was a good idea
>fly the dumbfucks to safety
>jedi masters assume the roles of generals, even though they have had no formal training of military strategy, and have no idea of what armaments the clones possess
>officer troops begrudgingly order their troops to form a big fucking wall and advance towards the other big fucking wall of approaching battle droids, since the jedi ordered so
>thousands die because of retarded jedi strategy
I bet the clones were fucking relieved when order 66 came around

I sure did. To see the mary sues die like bitches by being shot in the back was fucking exhilarating.

you know I've never thought of it this way...

Why didnt they just bombard the Droids with the proto-Star Destroyers

Why didn't they just ram the planet from hypser space

>i dont have to imagine a universe where order 66 was a good thing
>im living in it
Thanks for the feel good post op

because then you wouldn't be able to see people who are like 20,000 years technologically ahead of us do a literal medieval blob battle for no fucking reason

>even though they have had no formal training of military strategy
factually wrong, Jedi were studying various areas of knowledge. they were acting as space police for the republic, not only diplomats, I'm sure leading an ocasional rebelion or uprising was a part of the job. they were sages, they all studied history and strategy and space Art of War by space Sun Tzu was propably something they all read when they were younglings, and moved on to more advanced military treatises when older

Clone officers literally spent their entire life learning military strategy, and would obviously understand the ins and outs of their own weapons systems better than the jedi.

Jedi are space samurai. every samurai learned and read about military strategy on par with learning martial arts and swordsmanship.

The Clones were essentially biological droids. Which is one reason why it was fucking boring. It was literally droids fighting droids.

Why they dind't just hyperspace ram all of this?

tactics yeah, strategy absolutely not

Clone officers were 7 years old

Why would you destroy an entire planet when you could just destroy all of their cities from orbit? If they have naval superiority why even bother fighting on the ground?

clone officers learned tactics more than strategy I imagine since they were not supposed to be the leaders of entire armies. and Jedi were being assisted by the force, some had premonitionl that must have been useful.
all EU sources and Clone Wars cartoon say that clones didn't trust Jedi at first for the same reasons you're talking about, but came to recognising them as great warriors and leaders and respecting them. you can even see that in that in the third movie in relationship between Obi and Cody, the leader of Obi's legion

Why did the Empire build the Death Star?

Just hyperspace TIE fighter into planets. They can even be piloted by Force ghosts now.

Well technically it's a rebellion so the Republic would want to keep as much as possible intact.

>The Clones were essentially biological droids.
TAKE THAT BACK YOU FILTHY CLANKER-LOVER

>ITT: Weebs who think reading the Art of War and studying strategy for a few weeks makes you ready to lead an army.

Go back to studying the blade and mastering the block chain.

I'm no scientist, but I bet a Tie fighter hitting a planet at light speed would really fuck it up. Imagine the Coruscant version of 9/11.

You don't have to be a five star general to realize that American Civil War tactics aren't relevant in an Era of laser guns and lightspeed travel

Tie fighters don't have warp drives, x-wings would be a better comparison

God I felt like a faggot typing that sentence out

>The Clones were essentially biological droids.

>He's never seen The Clone Wars

>Tie fighters don't have warp drives
they do now

You are a faggot, but the newer tie fighters had a warp drive and shields. The ones with 3 panels. And i guess I'm a faggot too.
>not cannon

Fuck the canon, in listening to Path of Destruction and it'll never be not canon.

>The ones with 3 panels
You will speak of the Defender only with respect.

I couldn't remember the name and Wookipedia is a mess of pop-ups and ads, thanks.

Also, Vader's Tie Advanced had a hyper drive. Fuck the empire for being so cheap.

You are a a faggot. Also Reddit is superior.

#FuckDrumpf

just one of those ships could have FTL'd into the droids and the battle would be over

It looked really cool as a kid/teen and I'm sure out of all of those crazy vehicle designs you begged your parents for at least one toy

>hurr durrrfff the setting is stupid
then go watch something else
nothing more pathetic than someone who looks for shit to get mad about
or are you going to complain about the ships using regular naval tactics too?

Yoda arrives with the Clones. Jedi already have assumed control even before the battle began.

>They knew tactics not strategy
>Hurr Durr i frequent /his/ and think I'm a military expert

>it was real in my mind

So is Yoda that dick head FBI director that shows up after all the hard work has been done and "takes it from here."?

>what is a fictional setting
seriously, so many brainlets on here

Clones are trained by Jango and the latter ones are trained by random bounty hunters. Jedi never learnt military strategy, they learned to fight for whatever the Republic told them to like sheep.

>Trained by jango

Holy fuck you're dumb

He's right though, Jango trained officers and special units.

>just turn your brain off lmao

>regular naval tactics
>from the 1700's

Only jedi get force ghosts.

>medieval blob battle
Absolute brainlet

Naval warfare should be capped at age of sail-tier technology (but not materials).