ITT: Terrible film criticism

>the film was completely unnecessary

>it was soulless

>it didn’t age well

>it didn't have any plot

>they made darth vader into a whiny bitch

This is a valid complaint though.

>I couldn’t relate to the characters

>it wasn't fun

>it was ok

>nothing happens

>not diverse enough

>It made me feel disgusted

>it was sexist

>it was boring

>The wouldn't stand on its own without the

>midichlorians

>it's a good time, if you're drunk

>less than 15 posts before the thread devolves into Sup Forumstards whining again
Consider me impressed

>any film
>necessary
????

Sup Forums hated it

>thetans
That's completely valid

>it's problematic

I'm talking in the context of a franchise. For example, did we really need two spiderman reboots and a venom movie? Do we need modern sequels to classic 80s films?

>OH NO NO NO NO

Usually when people say a film isn't necessary, it's because it feels like filler and didn't have anything interesting to say. So the new Star Wars movies are unnecessary because they don't add anything to the story of Star Wars and are just vehicles for selling more toys.

>it feels like filler and didn't have anything interesting to say

>B R A V O N O L A N

The OT has nothing to say either

>it was too vanilla

This reply was completely unnecessary.

>without the context of “first movie” we have no reason to care about the events of this one

it's one of the definitive versions of the heroes journey?

Nah literature has that covered it wasn't necessary at all desu

I'm pretty sure I can live my life without ever needing to see Jabba the hut

But it, ultimately, falls flat.

>lacks strong female characters

>a mess

>appeals to morality when criticizing a slasher film

>hella diverse

Star Wars pretty much invented the space fantasy genre, so I would disagree.

Unnecessary genre the setting doesn't change the story

You don't really ever change the story, you just tell it in new ways, which the OT did. The archetypes are not our play things that we invent, it is the other way around.

"unnecessary" is the polite form of "cash grab"

>it doesn't follow the book

>*inhales*

>it was fun

>OH NO NO NO NO

>It was a good movie, but not a good (insert franchise) movie

No it didn't.

>it's reddit

Yes it did.

>the character(s) don't look like they are depicted in the book/comic/cartoon

>the audience didn't like it

>what does Sup Forums think?

No, that user was right. Star Wars belongs to the space opera genre and it didn't invent it. Lucas explicitly said it was influenced by Flash Gordon

>the character didn't react like I would've reacted, so it's bad writing

>Foley was over the top