Webcomic Tiers

hey, help me fill this out

>hardcore
Kit and Kay Boodle (read in its entirety)
Smackjeeves archives

>ascended
Randomly generated images from the PILGRIM sequencer
Pre-2006 Garfield online-only comics
"It's Time! A Webcomic About Time Travel"

Lego Robot is just "Sup Forums casual" tier

Not very "Hardcore"

>Jaded Outcast
Super Mega Comics
Jerkcity

>Hardcore
Lucid TV
Tails Gets Trolled

Why is oglaf so far down?

>Weird guy
Poppy O'Possum
Bittersweet Candy Bowl

>Ascended
Jack

Also should oglaf be kicked down a level, due to it's casual nudity and sex? I feel the others in that category are more sfw, but feel free to debate this.

Level 3 - It Hurts!!

if you tried to explain what oglaf was and why you read it to a normie then you would definitely be 'that weird guy'

>Electric Retard
>Googled it
>Fuck no

A comic with strong fantasy themes that makes sex jokes? Im not going to deny I am that weird guy, but oglaf never seemed that bad.

It Hurts!! under Hardcore probably

Put endtown on hardcore

The misconception of it being just cutesy fur shit is hilarious

I'd downgrade it to Weird or Jaded
It's not that WTF

Where would you put Overside?

Boxdog on level 6

Put VgCats on level 1 or 2.

it's something else. the guy who made electric retard got banned from Something Awful for posting pictures of him scraping the gunk out of his keyboard, cumming on it and then eating it.

MMO is updated on Vice.com lmao
Jerk City & Space Moose belong in that category though

Charts like these are generally meant to go from "entry level" to "obscure as fuck" to "pretty sure this doesn't actually exist". I'd put Endtown in Level 4.

The tipping point is when you jack it to an Oglaf strip. Which I have done.

It was the fruit-viking one.

Tails Gets Trolled should be at least at the same height as Electric Retard.

Ava's Demon
Unsounded
Lackadaisy
Latchkey Kingdom
Kill 6 billion demons

These have good art, hell Lackadaisy is fucking beautiful, but I feel like a lot of webcomics fall into the weird guy level, since they aren't that popular to normies unless they are #relateable or videogame comics. Also 2 are furry So into level 3 they go, but in the nice looking corner.

Sweet Bro and Hella Jeff on level 4

But webcomics are all shit. Maybe just have an image of a pile of shit and list all webcomics on top of it.

I'm not sure where to place Strong Female Protagonist.

here's one (You), it's all you get. Use it wisely.

Is xkcd really level 1? Sure, it's well known but a lot of the jokes aren't that accessible and some of them aren't even really jokes.
Anyway,

>SMBC-comics
level 1, since it basically belongs on the same tier as xkcd in terms of content

>Perry Bible Fellowship
level 3, I guess, since shit like dinosaur comics and oglaf are there. Really don't see how they qualify as being that weird, but ok.

put Junji Ito in general for either hardcore or ascended

>Junji Ito
>webcomics

Where do you kids place Order of the Stick?

weird guy- he is a good boy

In the trash

where would you guys put Sancta Cor

i haven't read a couple of these - if you spot something you feel should be in a higher or lower category, please say. also, oglaf is in level 3 because it's porn, let's face it. it's funny porn, but it's porn, and only weird kids read porn comics for fun.

Probably level 2-ish. You need at least a passing knowledge of fantasy literature/gaming tropes to care about it or even want to check it out. Then again, it's been years since I bothered checking it out so maybe things have changed.

Well you can go fuck yourself.

>Boxdog
>ascended
Shit nigga, I'd anything WeaverQuest is more ascended than fucking Boxdog.

It is crazy to me that something like Sonichu is so up in the list. Not that I disagree, but the whole situation keeps making me perplexed over the years.

Yeah, level 2 sounds fair.

>Jaded Outcast
Terrible Terrible Terrible/Habits

>Level 5
Sonic OC Sprite Comics in 2017

I do feel Tails gets trolled should be higher, and definitely not on the same level as jack. also judging from this thread it seems like tails gets trolled is moving around a lot. My vote is for hardcore, since it is pure uncontained autism that is entertaining and fun, whereas jack, from the chapters I have read is Highly edgy and does it in a disturbing way that left me asking myself why I read that.

yeah, i was reading through boxdog and it strikes me more as jaded outcast.

fair point, moved

i'd say it's not too far from homestuck, but a lot of homestuck's fanbase are too young to find SB&HJ funny.

Two contributions: Octopus Pie probably goes to Level 2. RockCocks Level 3

Where does 8-Bit theatre fit on this chart?

>tails gets trolled
>anything below that weird guy

El goonish shive should be level 3

Level 1: Sarah C Anderson

Level 3: Sarah C Anderson Sup Forums edits

It Hurts! on Jaded outcast.

SMBC should be Level 2. xkcd has a lot of stem humor, sure, but it's generally very agreeable even when the reader doesn't understand what's going on. SMBC is a bit less accessible in terms of tone and humor.

I've see It hurts treads in the catalog all the time, but I never read it, can you sell me on the plot, or should I not waste my time?

Does Garfield minus Garfield count as a webcomic? If it does, I'd put it on the same tier as Dinosaur comics. Re-using the same picture over and over is about as equally "weird" as removing Garfield from the comic strips.

plot: It hurts to read

is it painful?

Housepets! is definitely "That Weird Guy"
That one furry comic where furries run around in fursuits and there's a furry serial killer and one of the cops is a secret furry should be between Weird Guy and Outcast. Forget what it's called, Paradise Lost or something like that.

probably level 1 or 2.

>terrible terrible terrible
fucking love that sad possum

i agree but i can't move it now without leaving an ugly grey spot. when i reformat the list i'll put it on level 3.

Where does Paranormal or whatever its called fit?

I'll take the case!

>"Gamer"
VGcats
Scarygoround
Terminal Lance

>That weird guy
Unsounded
Lackadaisy Cats
Latchkey Kingdom
Mare Internum

>Jaded
Endtown
That one furry comic where the furries are literally persecuted, and it's a metaphor for some kind of religious discrimination. But in a different way from Endtown

>Hardcore
Where's my pipe?/ Fist of the Borf Star
Rubyquest/Nanquest

do you have the link to A Webcomic About Time Travel? it sounds familiar. is it about a guy who invents time travel and beats his teenaged self to death in a bathroom?

So my first post after being banned by the highly understandable merciful mods here in this beautiful and amazing place (/s), what about the massive trainwreck that Questionable Content is? Also now that we are talking about webcomic, I always wanted to remember the name of one of the 2 webcomics that I used to read like almost 7-10 years ago, it was a relative good draw by hand webcomic about a dude and its girlfriend/wife in you average US zombie apocalypse, the dude drop it though since because of its day job if Im not wrong, another Zombie related webcomic that used to read back in the day was The zombie hunters

So I guess I'm in the bottom panel, huh? What does that say about me?

Gag-a-Day with an overarching plot, starts off as kids doing normal stuff then shit hits the fan at Mach 10 at a certain point. It's pretty funny, read up to strip 100 to see if you want to see if it's your thing. Also the art starts off atrocious but becomes better really fast.

Bleedman's PPG comic in "That weird guy".

Gone With The Blastwave should be in Jaded.

>Skeleton Jelly

Isn't that like two pages long?

Fucked up kids that enjoy making each other laugh deal with increasingly difficult circumstances, get comfortable with them, and then up the ante.

what sort of bandwidth do you get at the bottom of the mariana trench?

Oyvind Thorsby in ascended.

Further submissions for your consideration, your honor

>Gamer
Brawl in the Family
Awkward Zombie
LOSS

>Jaded
Short run porn comics that don't have their own websites
Dreamkeepers, as much as I dislike it

throw moon over june on that bottom tier probably

There's this DA comic series of some guy's south park Thomas the train OC attempting to form a relationship with Serena from pokemon. It was posted on /vp/ for a few days and I haven't been able to find it since. If anyone knows the name I'll suck you off

Where does Erma fit in? It's not really distirbing or anything, but it is kind of obscure.

Yeah. It was some weird shit, after he killed his past self he went into full identity crisis mode because he still existed despite the fact that he just died. I think he started hallucinating for some reason, can't remember what but I remember the art got really fucked up for a bit.

Unfortunately I haven't thought about It's Time for years, and I don't remember which site hosted it.

Kit and Kay Boodle. That takes me back..

>Questionable Content is?
What happened to it, I'm in the arc were the Marteen starts dating the tranny of the memes and the fatty gets drunk and fired

Do Juan Cornella stuff count as "webcomic"?

You should stop reading it. If fact, I question why you even started reading it in the first place.

Okay guys. It's time for the two big ones
>Dumbing of Age
>Shortpacked
>Roomies
These need to be placed.

thank you harvey

that's true, but it holds a special place in my heart.

Where would you put the webcomic I never got around to making?

Slice of life, it's more of a habit, like reading newspaper comics. I started reading it because there were always those threads of QC so I got curious, same with RWBY (what happened to their generals BTW, I never went there tough) and gunnerkrig court.

So anyways, what's coming my way regarding QC that's so terrible?

A gradual decline into garbage, not even a funny explosive shitfest, just slow monotonous garbage. Enjoy.

>Randomly generated images from the PILGRIM sequencer
What the hell is that and how the hell did
it ended up in the same hole as electric retard, Jack or those sonic spirit comics?
>Ascended
The adventures of punchclops

Put Owlturd in level 1
Put TF2 comics in level 2

Penny Arcade for casul
DOA for gamer
SMBC for gamer

Also Camp Weedontwantcha for gamer

>Plastic Brick Automaton

My nigga

We need a tier below ascended if this is going to be realistic

About the same as Australia's.

Out of Placers in jaded outcast

I'd say "He Is A Good Boy" would be in Hardcore

Where would Ghastly's Ghastly Comic fit?

>brawl in the family level 2
>square root of minus garfield; put that wherever the hell you want

Kill six billion demons should be in either level 3 or 4.

>Casual
Pennyarcade

>Gamer
Hark! A Vagrant!
Octopus Pie

>That Weird Guy
The Adventures of Dr. McNinja
Girl Genius
Gunnerkrig Court
Axecop
Dresden Codak

>Jaded
Dumbing of Age is the very definition of this category, due to having a general dedicated to hating/analyzing the comic and it's author
Put Dobson comics in there as well
Roomies
Pictures for Sad Children
Wondermark
Least I Could Do

>Hardcore
Having large amounts of Pictures for Sad Children saved before the author deleted them
Ditto

Unless you are a hardcore "progressive" lefty with massive approval of SJW ideals, just stop reading for your own good, like this is not Sup Forums being contrarians into hate something (really rare occasion), QC truly went hard into pandering to that crowd so bad (that is coming from somone that is ok with "trannies" but is not part of the tumblr-esque lunacy)

But where does nedroid go?

>Unless you are a hardcore "progressive" lefty with massive approval of SJW ideals, just stop reading for your own good
>QC truly went hard into pandering to that crowd so bad

How bad are we talking?

Billy the heretic and Assigned male should have their own category below ascended

Is that Doug?