If one Ed didn't exist, how different would the other two Eds' lives be?

If one Ed didn't exist, how different would the other two Eds' lives be?

Attached: eds.png (611x1374, 955K)

if Eddie was gone the other two ed's would be two random kids on the street probably not really friends either

Without Eddy, Ed and Edd would just be outcasts and probably wouldn't even be friends.

Without Edd, Eddy wouldn't be able to get anything done. Ed would constantly get in his way.

Without Ed, scams would go a lot smoother, but Eddy would still butt heads with Edd and not have Ed to back him up. Ed represents the heart of the group, after all.

The Eds need each other, they couldn't reach their full potential otherwise.

If it was just Ed and Eddy, they'd struggle to come up with interesting scams since they'd lack the brainpower to really pull off more elaborate schemes, and they'd give up after the first few.

If it was just Edd and Eddy, they'd basically just sit around and talk about cool ideas they'd have for scams, but never actually do them because neither of them have the muscle to build larger/more elaborate things (to say nothing of being a living target)

And if it was just Ed and Edd, they wouldn't really do anything interesting at all, since they wouldn't have the drive to actually come up with stuff to do, and they'd essentially become background noise like the rest of the kids in the cul-de-sac.

Lots of EEnE threads today.

Without Ed they wouldn't have the manpower to actually build their shit because Eddy ain't swole enough to carry a fridge.

Edd is pretty well liked when he's not running one of Eddy's schemes. I doubt he would be an outcast

yeah, they're pretty great

The EEnE mmo taught me that this is excellent team comp. Unlike you faggot that do raids with the Kevin, Double D and Eddy composition

There was an episode where Eddy decides to disguise himself as a new student and both Edd and Ed were treated better without Eddy with them.

No Eddy: Edd just kind of avoids Ed
No Edd: Eddy's scams are regretably more low key and low tech without his inventions aiding him
No Ed: More (literally) lightweight scams because they don't have his muscle, but more of them succeed without Ed's bungling

No Eddy: Ed and Eddy would likely integrate in with the other kids fairly easily; Ed would be the lovable idiot that everyone is friendly with but don't go out of their way to hang out with, and Edd would be the weird brainy neurotic kid that they all like but get annoyed with his know-it-all-isms
No Edd: Eddy and Ed would likely get along, but Eddy's plans and schemes would likely be more low-key and prone to failure. Ed would stick around with Eddy because he's too dumb to recognize when he's just manipulating him.
No Ed: Edd and Eddy would likely hang out for a bit and participate in scams, but without Ed being the heart of the group, Edd would likely eventually get sick of Eddy's manipulativeness and ditch him.

Episode name?

He doesn't Jimmy Rolf and Plank

"Pick an Ed". It was one of the school season episodes.

this

Edd is the most popular of the eds but that's not saying much. Sarah has a crush on him and nazz is nice to him but it's been shown that Edd's dorkiness and social anxiety is very taxing on everyone's patience.

I agree on the first two, but the last one is incorrect. Both Ed and Edd are alright guys, the only reason they are alienated from the other kids is because of Eddy's scams. Ed has his heart in the right place and is great at sports, so he'd probably be friends with Kevin and Rolph. The kids like Edd even in the show, so he'd be well liked by everyone, even if not best friends with anyone. Their life wouldn't be as exciting, but probably better overall. Or maybe they'd even work together to build fun stuff for the kids minus the scam component.

Ed and Eddy without Edd would be like Okyasu and Josuke without Koichi

1 Of Mice and Men
2 Freak the Mighty
3 Rebecca Sucrose gay fan fiction.

>Without Eddy
Peaceful

>Without Edd
Really bad scams

>Without Ed
Good ideas to build a scam but no muscle to build it

better yet
replace one of the eds with another kid from the cul de sac but keep as much of the dinamyc as possible

Without Eddy, Ed and Edd would fit in better with the rest but probably also be more off doing their own thing like Johnny and Rolf often do.

Without Ed the formula would probably be somewhat similar to how it is now but Eddy would probably exploit Edd more and with their scams having a greater success rate. They’d probably be more antagonistic than the current formula.

Without Edd both Eddy and Ed would be lacking in moral and logical reasoning and most of their exploits would be like the racoon roundup scam and subsequent endeavors.

Like Phineas And Ferb basically?

I remember the kids being nicer to Eddy when he was pretending to be someone else, but they didn't really become more accepting of Edd and Ed. Kevin sees Eddy with Ed and Edd and asks "you know these dorks?"

Besides, I see Eddy as a catalyst for bringing Ed and Edd together. Ed is a destructive moron and Edd is a preachy know-it-all. The kids may be fond of them in small intervals, but it's never full-on acceptance. Heck, Edd and Ed get on each other's nerves too, and Eddy has to be the intermediary.

If one of them was a retard with herculean strength.

Ed and Eddy without Double D would go down like that episode of ATHF where Frylock moves out.

They likely would get themselves killed at some pont.

Edd, Eddy, and Rolf: Rolf isn't as stupid or as strong as Ed, but he is about as eccentric as Ed is dumb and has the insane determination to act as the groups muscle and get things built. Also I want to hear more stories about the Old Country.
Ed, Eddy, and Jonny & Plank: Jonny likes the scams more than the other kids and Plank is known to give out advice, which kinda sorta fills in for Edd's knowledge.
Ed, Edd, and Kevin: Kevin is more of a bully than a scam artist but he and Edd seemed to have some kind of friendliness between them and I can see him as someone who would try to take money from the other kids if he weren't friends with them.

Edd, Eddy and Rolf is the closest you could get while still sticking close to the original dynamic, the kids are all different enough that any change in the roster results in a pretty big shift.

Without Eddy the show would be about Edd trying to teach Ed and perform experiments involving him. It'd be Prometheus and Bob, basically.

Without Edd, Eddy and Ed would perform even more idiotic and morally questionable Scams (Eddy's first scam as a child was having people pay him to watch Ed eat objects). Eddy would probably still try to build things but they'd fail even more spectacularly.

Without Ed, Edd and Eddy would be more traveling salesman types. They'd sell minor things that Edd could build without Ed's help. The smaller scale scams would probably go even better than their normal ones but Eddy would probably cut corners with whatever snake oil they're hocking and they'd end up getting chased out of town by the end of the episode.

Out of all three I'd probably watch Ed and Edd.

without Edd, Ed and Eddy are those Two mobsters from Looney Tunes
without Ed its total fujoshit bait
without Eddy its a weird science show where Edd uses Ed for experiments

if we're talking alternate core trios I think Ed, Edd, and Sarah(in Eddy's role) would actually be a good combination, Sarah's not as clever as Eddy is(albeit the gap isn't as big as you'd think), but she's a lot more manipulative, and would be more willing to get physical to get scams to succeed, as for how the group dynamic changes up;

>Sarah is able to manipulate and control Ed very easily, so she'd probably handle him in scams easier than Eddy does a lot of the time

>in this situation I picture Edd as being Sarah's semi-unwilling boyfriend(in that Sarah didn't really give him an option to say no)

meanwhile Eddy and Jimmy become partners and rivals to Sarah's group in scamming the cul-de-sac

Attached: Edd & Sarah.gif (225x203, 361K)

STINKY HAT

Wouldn't Of Mice and Men be Ed and Eddy?

They'd integrate into the general group a little better at best but they'd never be friends which means they wouldn't really improve personally.

Without Edd around to coddle him, and make repeated attempts to bring his intelligence up Ed would probably just be a unhygienic meathead that ends up a loner due to his obsession with weird stuff and complete lack of social skills.

Without Ed Double-D would never leave his comfort zones, and thus have an ever harder time relating to the other kids. Double-D pines for greater social acceptance because he hates being ostracized when he thinks he has agreeable social traits and he does but like previously mentioned his general preachy-ness and neurotic tendencies tire the other kids pretty fast. If Double-D didn't have the other eds he'd grow up as a loner genius that hates his peers because he doesn't have anyone to connect to. Because of Ed Double-D is forced to learn tolerance for people distinctly different from himself, and because of Eddy he's forced to deal with Ed.

Edd/Sarah
cute